Dear ICErs,
thanks to those who attended the conference call this morning. Based on that conversation the following designations were made. The rationale is also included!
We are all quite happy so far with these designations!
Best,
Lindsey

Sent from my iPhone

Begin forwarded message:

From: "Campbell, John -FS" <jlcampbell@fs.fed.us>
Date: November 2, 2015 at 1:19:50 PM EST
To: "Rustad, Lindsey -FS" <lrustad@fs.fed.us>, "lindsey rustad (rustad@maine.edu) (rustad@maine.edu)" <rustad@maine.edu>
Subject: plot treatments

Hi Lindsey,

 

Below are the plot treatment assignments.  I included some notes about how the decisions

were made.  I also included the R script I wrote to do this.

 

PlotNo Treatment 

 [1,] "1"    "0.5 yr 2"

 [2,] "2"    "0.50 yr 1"

[3,] "3"    "0.25 yr 1"

[4,] "4"    "Control" 

 [5,] "5"    "0.75 yr 1"

[6,] "6"    "0.25 yr 1"

[7,] "7"    "Control" 

 [8,] "8"    "0.5 yr 2"

 [9,] "9"    "0.75 yr 1"

[10,] "10"   "0.5 yr 1"

 

Notes:

Plots were divided into two blocks based on position (Plots 1-5 and Plots 6-10).

each block will get one of the two replicate treatments assigned to it.

 

Treatments are as follows:

Control

0.25" in yr 1

0.50" in yr 1

0.75" in yr 1

0.50" in yr 1 and 2

 

Plots 4 and 7 were selected as controls because they contained

few sugar maple trees.  Since the controls are untreated, we can

use some nearby sugar maple trees from outside the plot.

 

Plot 1 was assigned a 0.5" treatment in year two because it is closer to

Hubbard Brook than plots 2-5, which will make it easier to spray.  Ian said

he would prefer to have the one he has to spray twice closer to the stream.

 

Plot 6 was selected as a 0.25" treatment because it is odd and the 0.25"

treatment was considered less important than the other treatments.

At plot 6 the lysimeter chemistry is different, the soils are rocky, and

the vegetation is not ideal (i.e., no red maple, not many trees).

 

R script used to assign treatments to plots:

 

PlotNo <- c(1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10)

Treatment <- c("0.5 yr 2","","","Control","","0.25 yr 1","Control","","","")

Assign <- cbind(PlotNo,Treatment)

 

Block_1_to_5 <- sample(c("0.25 yr 1","0.50 yr 1","0.75 yr 1"), 3, replace=F)

Block_6_to_10 <- sample(c("0.5 yr 1","0.5 yr 2","0.75 yr 1"), 3, replace=F)

 

Assign[2, "Treatment"] <- Block_1_to_5[1]

Assign[3, "Treatment"] <- Block_1_to_5[2]

Assign[5, "Treatment"] <- Block_1_to_5[3]

 

Assign[8, "Treatment"] <- Block_6_to_10[1]

Assign[9, "Treatment"] <- Block_6_to_10[2]

Assign[10, "Treatment"] <- Block_6_to_10[3]

Assign

 

Forest Service Shield

John L. Campbell, PhD
Research Ecologist

Forest Service

Northern Research Station

p: 603-868-7643
f: 603-868-7604
jlcampbell@fs.fed.us

271 Mast Rd.
Durham, NH 03824
www.fs.fed.us
http://wwwstatic.fs.usda.gov/images/email/usda-logo.pngTwitter LogoFacebook Logo

Caring for the land and serving people